
25 Years of Federal Court Immigration Decisions: What the Numbers Show
We reviewed 22,057 published Federal Court decisions on immigration refusals and mandamus from 2001 to 2026. Here is what the numbers show, and what they do not.
Immigration and Refugees Law
Reading Time
12 MINUTE READ
When a Canada visitor visa refused decision is issued, it indicates that the reviewing immigration officer was not satisfied on the evidentiary record that the foreign national met the statutory conditions for temporary admission. Under Canadian immigration law, applications for a tourist visa to Canada—categorized as Temporary Resident Visas (TRVs)—are governed strictly by the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR). At Pax Law Corporation, an immigration lawyer in Canada frequently evaluates these administrative decisions to determine whether the assessing officer applied the correct legal tests or rendered an unreasonable finding subject to challenge before the Federal Court.
The foremost statutory basis for the refusal of a Temporary Resident Visa is codified under paragraph 179(b) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (SOR/2002-227). Under this provision, an officer may issue a visa only if, following examination, it is established that the foreign national:
“will leave Canada by the end of the period authorized for their stay”
— IRPR, SOR/2002-227, s. 179(b)
Additionally, paragraph 183(1)(a) of the IRPR imposes a statutory condition requiring every temporary resident to depart Canada by the conclusion of their authorized period. Pursuant to subsection 183(2), the standard authorized duration of stay is six months, unless an officer authorizes a different duration based on the applicant’s financial resources, requested duration, and passport validity.
In Quraishi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2021 FC 1145, the Federal Court confirmed the allocation of the legal burden in TRV applications:
“A visa applicant has the onus to demonstrate their eligibility for a visa, including that they will leave Canada by the end of the authorized period.”
— Quraishi v. Canada, 2021 FC 1145 at para 12
The Court outlined at paragraph 13 that pertinent factors include the purpose and length of the visit, ties to Canada and to the applicant’s home country, financial ability, and travel and immigration compliance history. A subjective promise to leave is legally insufficient; the applicant must present objective, reliable documentary evidence.
| Refusal Ground | Statutory / Legal Authority | Core Evidentiary Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Unsatisfied Departure Intent | IRPR, s. 179(b) | Failure to establish that departure will occur prior to authorized stay expiry. |
| Weak Ties to Country of Residence | Federal Court Precedents (Shirazi; Quraishi) | Absence of stable employment, dependent family, active business, or real property. |
| Disproportionate Family Ties in Canada | Federal Court Precedents (Anand) | Close relatives in Canada operating as incentives to remain permanently. |
| Unclear or Unrealistic Purpose of Visit | IRPR, ss. 179(b), 179(d) | Vague itinerary, excessive visit length, or plans inconsistent with financial profile. |
| Insufficient or Unverified Funds | IRPR, s. 179(b); IRPA, s. 39 | Lump-sum deposits without origin proof, lack of banking history, or low declared income. |
| Immigration History Non-Compliance | IRPR, s. 179(b); IRPA, s. 16(1) | Prior overstays, unauthorized work or study, or undisclosed visa refusals. |
| Misrepresentation and Omissions | IRPA, s. 40(1)(a) | Withholding material facts or submitting false records (triggers 5-year entry bar). |
| Inadmissibility Grounds | IRPA, ss. 34–38 | Security grounds, serious criminality, organized criminality, or health concerns. |
When assessing whether an applicant’s temporary residence will culminate in a timely departure, the officer conducts a comparative analysis between the applicant’s ties to their home jurisdiction and their motivations to remain in Canada. In Shirazi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2024 FC 822, the Federal Court articulated this framework:
“Visa officers ‘must assess the strength of the ties that bind or pull the applicant to their home country against the incentives, economic and otherwise, that might induce the foreign national to overstay’.”
— Shirazi v. Canada, 2024 FC 822 at para 15
A finding of weak ties routinely stems from deficiencies such as:
Conversely, having significant family members in Canada—such as a spouse, children, parents, or siblings—may be viewed as an incentive to overstay. While having family in Canada is not an automatic ground for refusal, the applicant must establish why those connections do not outweigh their obligations back home. In Anand v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2019 FC 372, the Court affirmed the reasonableness of a refusal where the applicant had a child and two siblings in Canada with limited documented family ties remaining in India:
“It is not an error for the Officer to consider the strong family connection to Canada, especially when no evidence was proffered … to demonstrate family ties back to India.”
— Anand v. Canada, 2019 FC 372
Under paragraph 179(d) of the IRPR, the applicant must demonstrate an intention consistent with temporary admission. Decisions frequently result in a Canada visitor visa refused outcome when travel plans appear vague, unsubstantiated, or indicative of permanent settlement motives.
Common issues identified by officers include:
In Anand, the Court affirmed the officer’s conclusion that the applicant failed to prove they were a genuine visitor who would depart at the end of their stay:
“I am not satisfied on balance that PA is a bona fide visitor to Canada who will depart at the end of authorized stay.”
— Anand v. Canada, 2019 FC 372
However, officers are legally obligated to consider material evidence contradicting a negative finding. In Shirazi (at para 20), the officer doubted the applicant’s study purpose while ignoring evidence of a tangible job promotion offered by the applicant’s employer upon return. The Court determined the decision was unreasonable for ignoring evidence that demonstrated a clear personal benefit to departing Canada.
The assessment of financial resources in visitor visa applications occurs across two distinct legal frameworks:
Unlike select study permit pathways, the immigration regulations do not set a uniform, mandatory minimum dollar figure for a TRV. In Akhoondian v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 1181, the Federal Court confirmed:
“No similar statutory requirement exists for a TRV.”
— Akhoondian v. Canada, 2025 FC 1181 at para 9
Nevertheless, the applicant must establish sufficient resources to cover round-trip transit, accommodation, and subsistence without resorting to unauthorized employment. Sudden, unexplained large deposits, accounts lacking regular transactional history, or a modest declared income relative to estimated travel expenses frequently lead to refusals. In Anand, the officer highlighted insufficient proof of financial status and modest income on tax returns, an assessment upheld by the Court in the absence of evidence demonstrating local living costs in the home jurisdiction.
In addition to an officer’s general assessment of visit credibility, section 39 of the IRPA provides an independent ground of statutory inadmissibility:
“A foreign national is inadmissible for financial reasons if they are or will be unable or unwilling to support themself or any other person who is dependent on them, and have not satisfied an officer that adequate arrangements for care and support … have been made.”
— IRPA, SC 2001, c. 27, s. 39
A history of immigration non-compliance—such as visa refusals from Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom, or Australia, previous overstays, or working without authorization—materially impacts an application. While a prior refusal does not create a permanent statutory bar, failing to disclose it carries severe legal ramifications.
Subsection 16(1) of the IRPA requires every applicant to answer truthfully all questions put to them and produce all relevant evidence required by the officer. Furthermore, section 33 establishes that inadmissibility findings include facts arising from omissions.
Under paragraph 40(1)(a) of the IRPA, a permanent resident or foreign national is inadmissible for misrepresentation for directly or indirectly misrepresenting or withholding material facts relating to a relevant matter that induces or could induce an error in the administration of the Act. Pursuant to paragraph 40(2)(a), this finding results in a five-year ban from entering Canada.
In Risasi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2023 FC 1626, the Federal Court confirmed that intentional deceit is not required to ground a finding under section 40:
“Inadmissibility under paragraph 40(1)(a) is not limited to deliberate misrepresentations and does not require an intent to deceive… The onus is on the applicant to verify the completeness and accuracy of the application and to provide complete, honest and truthful information in every manner.”
— Risasi v. Canada, 2023 FC 1626 at para 18
Consequently, errors or omissions committed by third-party representatives, agents, or consultants remain the legal responsibility of the applicant.
Even if an applicant establishes sufficient ties and adequate funds, a temporary resident visa must be refused if statutory inadmissibility provisions apply:
Holding a visa does not guarantee admission. Under section 180 of the IRPR, a foreign national holding a TRV must continue to meet all statutory requirements at the port of entry examination. Furthermore, under section 180.1, an issued visa may be cancelled if the foreign national becomes inadmissible, fails to meet section 179 requirements, or has a subsequent application refused.
While the duty of procedural fairness in TRV assessments is limited, officers cannot rely on speculative credibility concerns without providing an opportunity to respond. In Hafiz v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2018 FC 1273, the Court distinguished between concerns arising strictly from statutory criteria and concerns relating to document credibility:
“Where however the issue is not one that arises in this context, such a duty may arise. This is often the case where the credibility, accuracy or genuine nature of information submitted by the applicant … is the basis of the visa officer’s concern.”
— Hafiz v. Canada, 2018 FC 1273
Moreover, officers must provide intelligible reasons rather than formulaic boilerplates. In Quraishi, the Federal Court held:
“A blanket or boilerplate statement that all information or all circumstances have been considered cannot reasonably take the place of explaining how those circumstances were considered and why the conclusion was reached.”
— Quraishi v. Canada, 2021 FC 1145 at para 26
Similarly, in Akhoondian (para 13), the Court reinforced that when boilerplate language read with the record fails to disclose whether proper criteria were applied, the decision lacks justification, intelligibility, and transparency.
A refusal of a TRV cannot be appealed on its merits to the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD). The primary legal recourse is an Application for Leave and Judicial Review before the Federal Court of Canada under section 72 of the IRPA.
Under Shirazi (at para 8), the Federal Court reviews TRV determinations under the reasonableness standard:
“Reasonableness review is a deferential and disciplined evaluation of whether an administrative decision is transparent, intelligible and justified.”
— Shirazi v. Canada, 2024 FC 822 at para 8
If the Court grants the application and finds the refusal unreasonable, it does not issue the visa directly. The Court quashes the refusal and remits the application for redetermination by a different immigration officer.
No. Under section 180 of the IRPR, a visa holder must demonstrate during examination at the port of entry that they continue to meet all eligibility and admissibility criteria to enter and remain as a temporary resident.
Yes. Pursuant to section 180.1 of the IRPR, an officer may cancel an issued TRV if the holder becomes inadmissible, fails to meet section 179 conditions, appears unlikely to depart, or if a subsequent application for a visa, work permit, or study permit is refused.
Under subsection 183(1) of the IRPR, temporary residents must depart by the end of their authorized stay, refrain from unauthorized work, refrain from unauthorized study, and comply with all statutory conditions imposed upon admission.
Yes. A refusal does not create a permanent legal bar unless a five-year inadmissibility finding for misrepresentation was rendered under section 40 of the IRPA. However, a new application must address the evidentiary gaps identified in the prior decision.
The information presented is for informational and educational purposes only and may not be accurate. This information does not replace getting legal advice from a qualified, practicing lawyer. If you are facing a legal dilemma, you should make an appointment and consult with one of our licensed and practicing lawyers.

We reviewed 22,057 published Federal Court decisions on immigration refusals and mandamus from 2001 to 2026. Here is what the numbers show, and what they do not.

Pax Law Corporation reviewed 22,057 published Federal Court decisions from February 2001 to November 2026. Samin Mortazavi appears as counsel for the applicant in 92 published decisions since 2019.

Lived together for years in Ontario? You may not have the same property rights as a married spouse. This guide and video explain equalization, support, unjust enrichment and cohabitation agreements.

دفتر وکالت پکس لا
پکس لا
سلام! وقت مشاورهی خود را بهسرعت از طریق واتساپ رزرو کنید. تیم ما در اسرع وقت پاسخ خواهد داد.

Pax Law Corporation
Pax Law
Hello! Book your consultation quickly via WhatsApp. Our team will reply as soon as possible.
Book a consultation with Pax Law Corporation and we will explain the options for your matter.
Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529This website provides general legal information only, not legal advice. Booking a consultation does not create a lawyer-client relationship until we confirm in writing. Outcomes cannot be guaranteed.
We use cookies to measure visits and improve this website. Choose whether to allow them.
0 Comments