
25 Years of Federal Court Immigration Decisions: What the Numbers Show
We reviewed 22,057 published Federal Court decisions on immigration refusals and mandamus from 2001 to 2026. Here is what the numbers show, and what they do not.
Reading Time
5 MINUTE READ
A section 44 report is not a deportation order. It signals an allegation of inadmissibility that may lead to further proceedings. The outcome depends on the applicable law, the evidence, and the person’s immigration status.
If you completed mandatory military service in Iran and were placed in the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), you may have had an application refused, or received a letter from the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) saying an officer has written a report against you under section 44 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA). The report usually alleges you are inadmissible on security grounds under paragraph 34(1)(f): membership in an organization said to engage in terrorism.
This post is for conscripts in that position, whether you are a permanent resident, a protected person whose PR application was refused, or a refugee claimant whose claim has been put on hold. It explains what happens next at the Immigration Division (ID), why these cases are hard, and how we approach them.
Canada listed the IRGC as a terrorist entity under the Criminal Code in June 2024. This designation may increase scrutiny of IRGC-related disclosures, but it does not, by itself, establish that every former conscript is inadmissible. The relevant IRPA provision and legal test must still be applied.
The process varies with immigration status, the inadmissibility ground, and the statutory procedures. A typical sequence is:
For refugee claimants, referral on specified inadmissibility grounds can suspend Refugee Protection Division proceedings under the applicable statutory provisions. The precise effect should be assessed in each case.
These cases are difficult because the law sets a low bar for the Minister and a high price for the person concerned.
No two conscription cases are identical, and Vadiati was decided on its own record. Our work at the ID focuses on building a record that is different, and on holding the Minister to what the law actually requires.
The ID decides the case afresh. The section 44 report is an allegation, not a finding. An earlier IRCC refusal does not bind the ID member. The Minister must establish reasonable grounds to believe each element, and the member must weigh all of the evidence, including evidence the officer never saw.
Disclosing service does not resolve the legal question. A statement that someone was assigned to the IRGC during mandatory service is evidence to be assessed. Whether the record establishes membership under paragraph 34(1)(f) is a separate legal question; compulsory assignment is relevant but not automatically decisive.
Conscript versus career member. Conscripts in Iran generally do not choose their branch. They are allocated, serve a fixed term, and leave at discharge. We build evidence on how the person entered, what they actually did, how long they served, whether they were ever promoted or re-enlisted, and how the service ended. The focus stays on the individual’s real duties, not on comparing organizations.
Statutory interpretation and Supreme Court guidance. In Mason v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2023 SCC 21, the Supreme Court interpreted paragraph 34(1)(e), not the membership provision in paragraph 34(1)(f). Its discussion of text, context, purpose, and international obligations may inform arguments where applicable, but it does not impose a general requirement to prove that an individual IRGC conscript personally poses a security threat under paragraph 34(1)(f).
Illustrative example. A conscript assigned to routine clerical duties for a fixed term, without command authority, may have documents explaining the nature and duration of service. Those facts warrant careful consideration, but do not independently establish that paragraph 34(1)(f) is inapplicable. This example is illustrative only. The legal significance of these facts depends on the evidence, the applicable authorities, and the person’s procedural circumstances.
Evidence aimed at the right questions. Typical evidence includes service and discharge documents, a detailed sworn declaration, witness statements, and country-condition and expert evidence on how Iranian conscription works. Each document is directed at a specific point in dispute, never offered as general corroboration of the allegation.
Disclosure and procedural fairness. Before taking a position, we seek full disclosure: CBSA interview notes, GCMS notes, and every prior application the Minister relies on, through the hearing process and access-to-information requests where needed. A person cannot fairly answer a case they have not seen.
Careful testimony preparation. Most of these hearings turn on credibility. We prepare clients to give consistent, accurate evidence through a qualified interpreter, and to explain honestly any gaps or differences from earlier statements.
Duress, used with care. Coercion is part of the story, but duress is rarely a standalone answer. Where it is raised, it is framed so it does not undercut the main position that membership is not established.
Preserving the next steps. We build the record so that, if the ID decides against the client, a strong judicial review is available. Decisions with severe consequences must be justified in a way that responds to the person’s central arguments. Where appropriate, we also prepare for Ministerial relief and for risk-based protection against removal, since protected persons cannot simply be returned to a place where they face persecution.
The first weeks matter most. What you say and file now will follow you to the hearing.
An early, evidence-based response can make a meaningful difference. No outcome is guaranteed: the available arguments depend on the person’s status, the record, and the applicable law.
Pax Law Corporation represents Iranian conscripts facing section 44 reports, Immigration Division hearings and Federal Court judicial review. To book a consultation, call 604-767-9529 or visit paxlaw.ca.
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Please consult a licensed lawyer or regulated immigration consultant about your situation.
The information presented is for informational and educational purposes only and may not be accurate. This information does not replace getting legal advice from a qualified, practicing lawyer. If you are facing a legal dilemma, you should make an appointment and consult with one of our licensed and practicing lawyers.

We reviewed 22,057 published Federal Court decisions on immigration refusals and mandamus from 2001 to 2026. Here is what the numbers show, and what they do not.

Pax Law Corporation reviewed 22,057 published Federal Court decisions from February 2001 to November 2026. Samin Mortazavi appears as counsel for the applicant in 92 published decisions since 2019.

Lived together for years in Ontario? You may not have the same property rights as a married spouse. This guide and video explain equalization, support, unjust enrichment and cohabitation agreements.

دفتر وکالت پکس لا
پکس لا
سلام! وقت مشاورهی خود را بهسرعت از طریق واتساپ رزرو کنید. تیم ما در اسرع وقت پاسخ خواهد داد.

Pax Law Corporation
Pax Law
Hello! Book your consultation quickly via WhatsApp. Our team will reply as soon as possible.
Book a consultation with Pax Law Corporation and we will explain the options for your matter.
Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529This website provides general legal information only, not legal advice. Booking a consultation does not create a lawyer-client relationship until we confirm in writing. Outcomes cannot be guaranteed.
We use cookies to measure visits and improve this website. Choose whether to allow them.
0 Comments