Immigration and Refugee Law

Duty of Truthfulness in Canadian Immigration: IRPA s. 16, Document Requests and the Link to Misrepresentation

Reading Time

12 MINUTE READ

Duty of Truthfulness in Canadian Immigration: IRPA s. 16, Document Requests and the Link to Misrepresentation

Anyone who applies to come to Canada or to stay in Canada takes on two basic duties under section 16 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA): to answer truthfully every question put to them, and to produce the documents and evidence that an officer reasonably requires. Failing to do so can lead to a refused application and, in some cases, to a finding of misrepresentation under section 40 with a five-year period of inadmissibility.

This article explains in plain English what section 16 requires, who it applies to, what happens when an answer is untrue or a document is not provided, how section 16 differs from misrepresentation under section 40, what procedural fairness requires, and what steps and options are available.

In this article

  1. What section 16 requires
  2. Who it affects
  3. The duty to answer truthfully
  4. The duty to produce documents and evidence
  5. What happens if you do not comply
  6. How section 16 links to misrepresentation under section 40
  7. Mistakes by a representative and the innocent mistake exception
  8. Procedural fairness: notice and a chance to respond
  9. Offences under sections 127 and 128
  10. Steps to take when you receive a request
  11. Common problems
  12. Options after a refusal or a finding
  13. When to get legal advice
  14. Key takeaways
  15. Official sources
  16. Frequently asked questions

What section 16 requires

Section 16(1) of IRPA says that a person who makes an application “must answer truthfully all questions put to them for the purpose of the examination and must produce a visa and all relevant evidence and documents that the officer reasonably requires”. The rest of section 16 adds related duties:

  • Section 16(1.1): a person who makes an application must, on request of an officer, appear for an examination.
  • Section 16(2): for a foreign national, the relevant evidence includes photographic and fingerprint evidence and, subject to the regulations, the foreign national must submit to a medical examination.
  • Section 16(2.1): a foreign national who makes an application must, on request of an officer, appear for an interview for an investigation by the Canadian Security Intelligence Service and must answer truthfully all questions put to them during the interview.
  • Section 16(3): an officer may require or obtain from a permanent resident or a foreign national who is arrested, detained, subject to an examination or subject to a removal order any evidence, photographic, fingerprint or otherwise, that may be used to establish their identity or compliance with the Act.

Two other provisions set the scene. Under section 15(1), an officer is authorized to proceed with an examination when a person makes an application. Under section 18(1), every person seeking to enter Canada must appear for an examination.

Who it affects

Section 16(1) applies to “a person who makes an application” under the Act. The Federal Court has applied it, for example, to a post-graduation work permit application (Dhamu v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 562), to a study permit extension (Pathak v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 1521) and to information requested about an applicant’s spouse (Galeshi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 1560).

Some parts of section 16 apply only to foreign nationals, such as the medical examination in section 16(2) and the interview in section 16(2.1). Section 16(3) also applies to permanent residents in the situations it lists.

The Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations add to these duties. Under section 10 of the Regulations, an application must be signed by the applicant, must include all information and documents required, must list all family members whether accompanying or not, and must include a declaration that the information provided is complete and accurate. Under section 12 of the Regulations, an application that does not meet the requirements of sections 10 and 11 is returned to the applicant.

The duty to answer truthfully

The duty covers “all questions put to them for the purpose of the examination”. In practice, questions are put to applicants in application forms, in letters from an officer and at interviews.

The courts describe this as a duty of candour. In Kazzi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2017 FC 153, the Federal Court said at paragraph 38 that an applicant has the onus and a continuing duty of candour to provide complete, accurate, honest and truthful information. In that case the Court upheld a misrepresentation finding based on repeated failures to disclose an arrest and detention, and rejected the argument that an amnesty justified the answers given.

The duty is not limited to facts that would change the result. In Shafique v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2023 FC 226, the Court upheld a refusal under section 16(1) based on untrue answers about earlier visa applications. It held at paragraph 13 that, unlike section 40, section 16(1) does not require materiality. The requirement is only relevance.

Answering one specific request does not end the duty. In Baro v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2007 FC 1299, the applicant provided the marriage certificate that was requested, but the Court held at paragraph 18 that this did not relieve him of the obligation to disclose his previous marriage. At the same time, in Bodine v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2008 FC 848, the Court said at paragraph 42 that section 40 does not require a person to spontaneously disclose every fact that could possibly be relevant. Whether withholding information is a misrepresentation depends on the surrounding circumstances.

The duty to produce documents and evidence

An applicant must produce “all relevant evidence and documents that the officer reasonably requires”. The wording contains two limits: the evidence must be relevant, and the officer’s request must be reasonable.

  • In Dhamu, the applicant did not provide a credential report that the officer had requested and did not explain why. The Court found the request relevant in the context of the application and upheld the refusal.
  • In Pathak, the applicant sent an unofficial transcript when an official transcript had been requested. The Court found at paragraph 15 that the request was reasonable and upheld the refusal.
  • In Galeshi, repeated requests produced unclear and conflicting information about the education and employment of the applicant’s spouse. The Court upheld a refusal based on sections 16(1) and 41.

What happens if you do not comply

The most common result is that the application is refused for non-compliance with section 16. For a foreign national, section 41(a) also provides that a person is inadmissible for failing to comply with the Act through an act or omission that contravenes, directly or indirectly, a provision of the Act. For permanent residents, section 41(b) is limited to failing to comply with section 27(2) or section 28.

An application can be refused for non-compliance without any finding of misrepresentation. The five-year period in section 40(2)(a) attaches to a misrepresentation finding under section 40, not to a refusal for non-compliance alone.

How section 16 links to misrepresentation under section 40

Section 40(1)(a) makes a permanent resident or a foreign national inadmissible for misrepresentation “for directly or indirectly misrepresenting or withholding material facts relating to a relevant matter that induces or could induce an error in the administration of this Act”. The two sections overlap, but they are not the same:

  • The test. Section 16(1) asks whether the question or document was relevant. Section 40 also requires that the facts be material and that the misrepresentation or withholding induces or could induce an error (Shafique, paragraph 13; Dhamu, paragraph 15).
  • The consequence. Under section 40(2)(a), the person continues to be inadmissible for five years following a final determination of inadmissibility made outside Canada or, for a determination made in Canada, the date the removal order is enforced. Under section 40(3), a foreign national who is inadmissible under section 40 may not apply for permanent resident status during that period.
  • The overlap. A failure to provide a requested document may also be treated as evidence that material facts were withheld, but it does not automatically meet the section 40 test.

For more on section 40, see our article on misrepresentation and the five-year ban.

Mistakes by a representative and the innocent mistake exception

Section 40 covers misrepresentations made “directly or indirectly”. In Goburdhun v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2013 FC 971, the Federal Court summarized the case law at paragraph 28: section 40 is worded broadly enough to cover misrepresentations made by another party, including an immigration consultant, without the applicant’s knowledge.

  • In Oloumi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 428, and Sayedi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 420, fraudulent language test documents were attributed to consultants. The Court upheld the findings and said in Oloumi at paragraph 51 that section 40 has no subjective intent or knowledge requirement.
  • In Wang v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2005 FC 1059, a dependent spouse was found to have misrepresented indirectly through the principal applicant’s application, although she did not know about it.

There is a narrow exception for an innocent mistake. It traces back to Medel v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1990] 2 FC 345 (FCA), decided under the former Immigration Act, where the Federal Court of Appeal found that the appellant reasonably believed she was withholding nothing relevant. Under Goburdhun, the exception applies only in truly extraordinary circumstances, where the applicant honestly and reasonably believed they were not misrepresenting a material fact and knowledge of the misrepresentation was beyond their control.

The exception is hard to meet. In Appiah v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2018 FC 1043, the applicant said he had forgotten a study permit application refused about sixteen years earlier. The Court was not prepared to find the officer unreasonable for rejecting that explanation. But an officer must deal with the explanation: in Gill v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2021 FC 1441, the Court set the decision aside because the officer had not adequately justified rejecting the claimed mistake.

Procedural fairness: notice and a chance to respond

In Mansooryan v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2024 FC 1718, the Federal Court said at paragraph 30 that a concern about misrepresentation triggers a higher level of procedural fairness than general visa applications. This normally means adequate notice of the concern and a meaningful opportunity to respond, often through a procedural fairness letter.

There is no rule that a letter is sent in every case. In Tayabi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2023 FC 453, the Court observed at paragraph 29 that many foreign nationals do not receive a procedural fairness letter and must make their case in their original submissions.

An applicant cannot fairly be refused for failing to answer a letter that was never sent. In Entezamfar v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 141, a refusal for not providing police certificates, bank statements and other documents was set aside because the letter requesting them had not been sent to the applicant.

See also our article on procedural fairness letters and how to respond.

Offences under sections 127 and 128

Separately from refusals and inadmissibility, section 127 of IRPA makes it an offence to knowingly misrepresent or withhold material facts relating to a relevant matter that induces or could induce an error in the administration of the Act, or to knowingly refuse to answer a question put to the person at an examination or at a proceeding held under the Act. Under section 128, the penalty is a fine of not more than $100,000 or imprisonment for not more than five years, or both, on conviction on indictment, and a fine of not more than $50,000 or imprisonment for not more than two years, or both, on summary conviction. These offence provisions are distinct from an administrative finding under section 16, 40 or 41.

Steps to take when you receive a request

  1. Read the request carefully. Note what is asked for, the deadline and how the response must be sent.
  2. Answer every question completely. If a question does not apply to you, say so instead of leaving it blank.
  3. Disclose your history. The cases above involved an undisclosed visa refusal (Goburdhun), an arrest and detention (Kazzi), a previous marriage (Baro) and an old refused application (Appiah).
  4. Send exactly what was requested. If the request is for an official document, an unofficial one may not be enough (Pathak).
  5. If you cannot get a document, say so in writing before the deadline. Explain why and offer other evidence. In Dhamu, the applicant neither provided the report nor explained its absence.
  6. Check everything a representative prepares. You sign the application and declare that it is complete and accurate.
  7. If you find an error in something already submitted, get legal advice promptly about how to correct it.
  8. Keep copies of everything you send and proof of when you sent it.

Common problems

  • Answering “no” to a question about past refusals, charges or arrests because the event was long ago or happened in another country.
  • Signing forms prepared by someone else without reading them.
  • Dates and details that do not match earlier applications.
  • Leaving out family members who are not coming to Canada.
  • Letting a deadline pass without sending the document or an explanation.
  • Assuming that only important facts must be disclosed. Section 16(1) asks only whether the question is relevant.

Options after a refusal or a finding

The options depend on the decision. After a refusal for non-compliance, some people make a new application with complete and accurate information. Earlier applications and refusals remain part of the person’s history and must be disclosed.

Many immigration decisions can be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review in the Federal Court under section 72(1) of IRPA. The Court does not rehear the case. It reviews whether the decision was reasonable and procedurally fair. Strict deadlines apply. See our immigration judicial reviews page.

A person who is inadmissible may in some cases ask for a temporary resident permit under section 24(1) of IRPA, which is discretionary.

Pax Law Corporation lawyers have Federal Court decisions published on CanLII. You can see them on our court decisions page. Every case is different and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

When to get legal advice

Consider speaking with a lawyer as soon as you receive a document request you cannot meet, an interview notice, a procedural fairness letter that mentions misrepresentation, or a refusal that cites section 16, 40 or 41. It is also sensible to get advice if you discover an error in an application that is still in process. You can read more about our immigration services.

Key takeaways

  • Section 16(1) requires truthful answers to all questions and the production of relevant evidence and documents that an officer reasonably requires.
  • Section 16(1) requires relevance, not materiality (Shafique; Dhamu).
  • Non-compliance can lead to refusal and, for foreign nationals, inadmissibility under section 41(a).
  • Misrepresentation under section 40 is a separate finding with a five-year period of inadmissibility.
  • A representative’s error is usually attributed to the applicant, and the innocent mistake exception is narrow (Goburdhun; Oloumi).
  • A misrepresentation concern calls for notice and a meaningful chance to respond (Mansooryan).

Official sources

Frequently asked questions

What does section 16 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act require?

A person who makes an application must answer truthfully all questions put to them for the purpose of the examination and must produce a visa and all relevant evidence and documents that the officer reasonably requires.

Who has to comply with section 16?

Section 16(1) applies to a person who makes an application under the Act. Some parts, such as the medical examination in section 16(2), apply only to foreign nationals.

Does a fact have to be important before I must answer truthfully about it?

No. In Shafique, 2023 FC 226, and Dhamu, 2026 FC 562, the Federal Court said that section 16(1) does not require materiality. The requirement is only relevance.

Can my application be refused only because I did not send a requested document?

Yes, if the document is relevant and the officer’s request is reasonable. In Pathak, 2025 FC 1521, a refusal was upheld where an unofficial transcript was sent instead of the official transcript requested.

Is a refusal under section 16 the same as misrepresentation?

No. An application can be refused for non-compliance without a misrepresentation finding. Section 40 also requires that material facts were misrepresented or withheld and that this induces or could induce an error in the administration of the Act.

What is the five-year bar?

Under section 40(2)(a), a person found inadmissible for misrepresentation continues to be inadmissible for five years. Under section 40(3), a foreign national may not apply for permanent resident status during that period.

What if my consultant or a family member made the mistake?

In Goburdhun, 2013 FC 971, the Federal Court said section 40 covers misrepresentations made by another party, including an immigration consultant, without the applicant’s knowledge. In Wang, 2005 FC 1059, a dependent spouse was caught by the principal applicant’s misrepresentation.

Is there an exception for an honest mistake?

There is a narrow exception. Under Goburdhun it applies only in truly extraordinary circumstances, where the applicant honestly and reasonably believed they were not misrepresenting a material fact and knowledge of the misrepresentation was beyond their control.

Will I always get a procedural fairness letter first?

Not always. In Mansooryan, 2024 FC 1718, the Court said a misrepresentation concern triggers a higher level of procedural fairness, but in Tayabi, 2023 FC 453, it noted that many foreign nationals do not receive a procedural fairness letter.

What if I never received the letter asking for documents?

In Entezamfar, 2026 FC 141, the Federal Court set aside a refusal because the letter requesting documents had not been sent to the applicant.

Can giving false information be an offence?

Yes. Section 127 makes it an offence to knowingly misrepresent or withhold material facts, and section 128 sets out fines and imprisonment. These provisions are separate from an administrative refusal.

Can I challenge a refusal in court?

Many decisions can be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review in the Federal Court under section 72(1) of the Act. Strict deadlines apply, so get legal advice quickly.

Book a consultation

If you have received a document request, an interview notice or a procedural fairness letter, a lawyer at Pax Law Corporation can review it with you.

Follow Pax Law Corporation

For more on Canadian law: subscribe on YouTube · Instagram @paxlawcorp · TikTok @paxlaw

Disclaimer: This article is general legal information only, not legal advice. It reflects the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations and the court decisions cited as of the date of publication. Laws change and every case is different, so speak with a lawyer about your own circumstances. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Table of Contents

Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529