Immigration and Refugee Law

One Missing Answer Can Mean a Five-Year Ban: Misrepresentation Under IRPA s. 40 (Video)

Reading Time

6 MINUTE READ

One Missing Answer Can Mean a Five-Year Ban: Misrepresentation Under IRPA s. 40 (Video)

Misrepresentation under section 40 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) can lead to five years of inadmissibility, even without intent. A missing answer or an incomplete form can be enough if the information was material. This guide and video explain how section 40 works, what the innocent mistake exception means, and what to do if you receive a procedural fairness letter. This is general information only, not legal advice.

Video: One Missing Answer Can Mean a Five-Year Ban

For more videos on Canadian law, subscribe to the Pax Law YouTube channel.

What counts as misrepresentation under s. 40(1)(a)

Under IRPA s. 40(1)(a), a permanent resident or foreign national is inadmissible for directly or indirectly misrepresenting or withholding material facts relating to a relevant matter that induces or could induce an error in the administration of the Act. Two points stand out:

  • the rule covers withholding facts as well as stating something false; and
  • it applies if the misrepresentation could induce an error, so it does not need to have actually changed the outcome.

The five-year period

Under s. 40(2)(a), the inadmissibility lasts five years. For a determination made outside Canada, the period runs from the final determination. For a determination made in Canada, it runs from when the removal order is enforced. Under s. 40(3), a foreign national found inadmissible under this section cannot apply for permanent resident status during that period.

The innocent mistake exception

Section 40 does not itself contain an innocent mistake exception, but the Federal Court has recognized one. In Baro v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2007 FC 1299, the Court held that an applicant avoids inadmissibility only by showing an honest and reasonable belief that no material information was being withheld. In that case, the applicant did not meet that standard. Whether a particular mistake qualifies depends on the facts, so each situation needs careful review.

What is a procedural fairness letter?

If an officer has concerns that you may have misrepresented or withheld something, you are usually sent a procedural fairness letter before any final decision. It sets out the concern and gives you a chance to respond. The response is your opportunity to explain what happened and to provide documents. Because a finding of misrepresentation can have lasting consequences, the way you respond matters, and many people choose to speak with a lawyer first.

Federal Court judicial review (s. 72)

If a decision is made against you, a judicial review in the Federal Court may be possible under IRPA s. 72. It requires leave of the Court, and the time limits are strict: as explained in the video, the application for leave must be filed within 15 days for a matter arising in Canada, or 60 days for a matter arising outside Canada, after the day you are notified of or otherwise become aware of the decision. A judge may extend the time only for special reasons. The Court usually asks whether the decision was reasonable and procedurally fair, not whether it would have decided the matter differently. See also Federal Court decisions our lawyers have won; past results do not predict future outcomes.

Practical points

Misrepresentation can arise on visitor visa, study permit, work permit and permanent residence applications. Three practical points from the video:

  • answer every question completely, including prior refusals, travel history and any criminal record;
  • review every form before you sign it; and
  • remember that a mistake by a representative can still be treated as your responsibility.

The information must also be material. It does not have to be decisive: the Federal Court has said it must be important enough to affect the process (Paashazadeh v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 327), and it must be linked to a possible error in administering the Act.

Other pages that may help

Sources

Sources: Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, SC 2001, c 27, ss. 40(1)(a), 40(2)(a), 40(3) and 72; Baro v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2007 FC 1299; Paashazadeh v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 327. Laws change, so check the current version before acting.

Frequently asked questions

What is misrepresentation under IRPA s. 40?

Under s. 40(1)(a), directly or indirectly misrepresenting or withholding material facts relating to a relevant matter that induces or could induce an error in the administration of the Act.

How long does the inadmissibility last?

Under s. 40(2)(a), five years. The start date depends on whether the determination was made in or outside Canada.

Does it matter if I did not intend to mislead?

Intent is not part of the wording of s. 40(1)(a), but the Federal Court has recognized an innocent mistake exception in limited situations.

What is the innocent mistake exception?

In Baro v. Canada, 2007 FC 1299, the Federal Court said an applicant avoids inadmissibility only by showing an honest and reasonable belief that no material information was being withheld.

Can leaving out an answer be misrepresentation?

It can be, because s. 40(1)(a) covers withholding material facts, not only false statements.

What does “material” mean?

Information does not have to be decisive to be material; it must be important enough to affect the process (Paashazadeh v. Canada, 2015 FC 327). Whether a fact is material depends on the application and the facts.

Can I apply for permanent residence during the five years?

Under s. 40(3), a foreign national found inadmissible under this section cannot apply for permanent resident status during that period.

What is a procedural fairness letter?

A letter from an officer setting out a concern and giving you a chance to respond before a decision is made.

Should I respond to a procedural fairness letter?

Responding is usually your opportunity to explain and provide documents. Because the consequences can be serious, many people speak with a lawyer first.

Can I challenge a decision in Federal Court?

Possibly. Under IRPA s. 72, a judicial review requires leave of the Court. As explained in the video, the application for leave must be filed within 15 days (matter arising in Canada) or 60 days (matter arising outside Canada) after you are notified of or otherwise become aware of the decision.

What does the Federal Court review?

Usually whether the decision was reasonable and procedurally fair, not whether the Court would have decided differently.

Is this legal advice?

No. This is general information only. Every situation is different and no outcome is guaranteed.

How do I book a consultation?

Use the booking section at the bottom of this page.

Book a consultation

Received a procedural fairness letter, or worried about an answer on an application? Book a confidential consultation with Pax Law Corporation. You can also see our immigration services.

Follow Pax Law

For updates on Canadian law, follow us on Instagram, subscribe on YouTube and follow us on TikTok.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Every situation is different and no outcome is guaranteed. It reflects Canadian law as of the date of publication, and laws change. Past results do not predict future outcomes.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Table of Contents

Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529