Immigration and Refugee Law

Humanitarian and Compassionate Permanent Residence: IRPA s. 25 and Its Limits

Reading Time

6 MINUTE READ

Humanitarian and Compassionate Permanent Residence: IRPA s. 25 and Its Limits

Many people believe that once they file a humanitarian and compassionate (H&C) application for permanent residence, they cannot be removed from Canada. That is not correct. Under section 25 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), the Minister can examine a person’s circumstances, but there are important limits. This guide explains what an H&C application is, what is considered and what is not. This is general information only, not legal advice.

What is an H&C application for permanent residence?

Under IRPA s. 25(1), at the request of a foreign national in Canada, the Minister must examine their circumstances. If the person does not meet the usual requirements for permanent residence, the Minister may grant permanent resident status, or an exemption from some requirements of the Act, on humanitarian and compassionate grounds. The best interests of any child directly affected must be taken into account.

The limits in section 25

Under s. 25(1.2), the Minister may not examine the request in these situations, among others:

  • the person has already made such a request and it is still pending;
  • the person’s refugee claim is still pending before the Refugee Protection Division or the Refugee Appeal Division; or
  • less than 12 months have passed since the refugee claim was rejected, withdrawn or abandoned.

Under s. 25(1.21), the 12-month bar does not apply if removing the person would put their life at risk because each of their countries of nationality cannot provide adequate health or medical care, or would have an adverse effect on the best interests of a child directly affected.

What is considered, and what is not

Under s. 25(1.3), when the request is made from within Canada, the Minister may not consider the factors that are taken into account in deciding whether someone is a refugee or a person in need of protection. In other words, the risks assessed in a refugee claim are not reassessed in this application. However, the hardships the person would face must still be considered.

Kanthasamy and the Supreme Court of Canada

In Kanthasamy v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 SCC 61, the Supreme Court of Canada said this provision is meant to offer relief to people whose circumstances would excite in a reasonable person the desire to relieve their misfortunes. The Court also explained that leaving Canada will always involve some hardship, which on its own will not generally be enough, and that s. 25 is not an alternative immigration scheme. The officer must weigh all the relevant circumstances together, such as the person’s establishment in Canada, family ties, the best interests of any children, and the hardship the person would face if the application is refused.

Filing an H&C application and removal

Filing this application does not by itself stop your removal. If you have a removal order, think about your other options based on your circumstances and speak with a lawyer before you decide. Every case is different and no outcome is guaranteed.

Sources

Sources: Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, SC 2001, c 27, ss. 25(1), 25(1.2), 25(1.21) and 25(1.3); Kanthasamy v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 SCC 61. Laws change, so check the current version before acting.

Frequently asked questions

What is an H&C application for permanent residence?

Under IRPA s. 25(1), it is a request by a foreign national in Canada for the Minister to grant permanent residence, or an exemption from some requirements, on humanitarian and compassionate grounds.

If I file this application, can I still be removed?

Yes. Filing the application does not by itself stop removal.

Are children’s interests considered?

Yes. Under s. 25(1), the best interests of a child directly affected must be taken into account.

What if my refugee claim is still pending?

Under s. 25(1.2), the Minister may not examine the request while the claim is pending before the Refugee Protection Division or Refugee Appeal Division.

What if my refugee claim was rejected?

Under s. 25(1.2), the request is generally not examined if less than 12 months have passed since the claim was rejected, withdrawn or abandoned, except in the situations set out in s. 25(1.21).

When does the 12-month bar not apply?

Under s. 25(1.21), if removal would put your life at risk because your country cannot provide adequate health or medical care, or would harm the best interests of a child directly affected.

Are the risks from my refugee claim reconsidered?

No. Under s. 25(1.3), the factors used to decide refugee or protected-person status are not considered, but the hardships you would face are.

What is Kanthasamy?

Kanthasamy v. Canada, 2015 SCC 61, is the Supreme Court of Canada decision explaining the purpose of s. 25 and how H&C applications are assessed.

Is the hardship of leaving Canada enough on its own?

Generally, no. The Supreme Court said leaving Canada always involves some hardship, which on its own will not generally be enough.

What does the officer weigh?

All the relevant circumstances together, such as establishment in Canada, family ties, the best interests of children and the hardship you would face if refused.

Is this an alternative to the regular immigration programs?

No. The Supreme Court said s. 25 is not an alternative immigration scheme.

Is this legal advice?

No. This is general information only. Every situation is different and no outcome is guaranteed.

How do I book a consultation?

Use the booking section at the bottom of this page.

Book a consultation

Have questions about a humanitarian and compassionate application or your status in Canada? Book a confidential consultation with Pax Law Corporation.

Follow Pax Law Corporation

For more on Canadian law: subscribe on YouTube · Instagram @paxlawcorp · TikTok @paxlaw

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Every situation is different and no outcome is guaranteed. It reflects federal immigration law as of the date of publication, and laws change. Past results do not predict future outcomes.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Table of Contents

Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529