Criminal Law

The Jordan Decision: Trial Delay, Section 11(b) and Stays of Proceedings in Canada

Reading Time

9 MINUTE READ

The Jordan Decision: Trial Delay, Section 11(b) and Stays of Proceedings in Canada

Section 11(b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms gives every person charged with an offence the right to be tried within a reasonable time. In 2016, the Supreme Court of Canada decided R. v. Jordan, 2016 SCC 27 and replaced the old, case-by-case approach with presumptive time limits: 18 months for cases tried in provincial court and 30 months for cases tried in superior court. When those limits are exceeded without a valid justification, the usual remedy is a stay of proceedings, which stops the prosecution.

This guide explains, in plain language, how the Jordan framework works, how delay is counted, what “exceptional circumstances” are, and why a stay for delay is not always the end of the story. We use the Ontario case of R. v. Picard, where a murder charge was stayed for delay and the stay was later lifted on appeal, to show how these rules play out. This article is general legal information for people in British Columbia, Ontario and elsewhere in Canada, not legal advice.

Watch: The Jordan Decision Explained

For more videos on Canadian law, subscribe to the Pax Law Corporation YouTube channel.

What is the right to be tried within a reasonable time?

Section 11 of the Charter lists the rights of “any person charged with an offence”. Paragraph 11(b) says that person has the right “to be tried within a reasonable time”. The right protects the accused person, who lives with the stress, cost and uncertainty of an outstanding charge, and it also protects the public interest in timely justice for victims, witnesses and the community.

Under the Jordan framework, delay is measured from the date the person is charged to the actual or anticipated end of the trial (Jordan, paras. 47 and 60). Section 11 protects a person after they are charged, so time spent investigating before a charge is laid is not counted (R. v. Kalanj, [1989] 1 S.C.R. 1594).

Who it affects

Section 11(b) applies to every criminal prosecution in Canada, whether in the Provincial Court of British Columbia, the Supreme Court of British Columbia, the Ontario Court of Justice or the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. It matters to:

  • people charged with a criminal offence whose case is taking a long time;
  • people who are deciding whether to agree to an adjournment or a later trial date;
  • families of accused persons and complainants who want to understand why a case may be stayed;
  • permanent residents and foreign nationals, because the outcome of a criminal case can affect immigration status.

The Jordan ceilings: 18 months and 30 months

The Supreme Court set two presumptive ceilings (Jordan, para. 46):

  • 18 months for cases going to trial in provincial court; and
  • 30 months for cases going to trial in superior court, or cases going to trial in provincial court after a preliminary inquiry.

If the net delay (explained below) is above the ceiling, it is presumed to be unreasonable. The Crown can rebut that presumption only by showing exceptional circumstances. If it cannot, the delay is unreasonable and a stay will follow (Jordan, para. 47).

How delay is counted: subtracting defence delay

The court starts with the total delay from charge to the actual or anticipated end of trial. It then subtracts defence delay, which has two parts (Jordan, paras. 61 and 66):

  • Delay the defence waived. A waiver can be explicit or implicit, but it must be clear and unequivocal, and the accused must understand the right and the effect of giving it up.
  • Delay caused solely or directly by the defence. For example, where the court and the Crown are ready to proceed but the defence is not.

Steps the defence legitimately takes to respond to the charges are not deducted. In R. v. Cody, 2017 SCC 31, the Supreme Court explained that the only deductible defence delay of this kind is delay that is caused solely or directly by the accused and that flows from illegitimate defence action, meaning action not taken to respond to the charges (Cody, para. 30). An application designed to delay, or one marked by inefficiency or indifference toward delay, may be illegitimate, and the timeliness of defence applications can be relevant (Cody, para. 32). The Court also expects defence counsel to actively advance the accused person’s right to a trial within a reasonable time (Cody, para. 33).

Exceptional circumstances

When the net delay is above the ceiling, the Crown may try to justify it with exceptional circumstances. These are circumstances outside the Crown’s control: they were reasonably unforeseen or reasonably unavoidable, and Crown counsel could not reasonably remedy the delay they caused (Jordan, para. 69). There are two general categories (Jordan, para. 71):

  • Discrete events, such as an unexpected illness or another event that could not reasonably have been prevented. The delay caused by the event is subtracted.
  • Particularly complex cases, where the nature of the evidence or the issues means the case reasonably needs more time.

For charges laid before Jordan was released in 2016, the Court also created a transitional exceptional circumstance. It applies where the Crown satisfies the court that the time taken is justified by the parties’ reasonable reliance on the law as it previously existed (Jordan, para. 96).

Cases below the ceiling

A case can still breach section 11(b) even if the net delay is below the ceiling, but the burden shifts to the defence. The defence must show two things (Jordan, para. 82):

  1. it took meaningful steps that show a sustained effort to expedite the proceedings; and
  2. the case took markedly longer than it reasonably should have.

If either is missing, the application fails. In practice, stays below the ceiling are uncommon, which is one reason the defence should put its concerns about delay on the record early.

What happened in Jordan itself

Jordan came from British Columbia. After committal, the case moved to the Supreme Court of British Columbia for trial (Jordan, para. 10). The total delay was 49.5 months (para. 12). The defence was responsible for 5.5 months: 4 months it waived and 1.5 months it caused, leaving a net delay of 44 months (para. 124), well above the 30-month ceiling. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the convictions and entered a stay of proceedings (para. 135).

R. v. Picard: a murder charge stayed and revived

The Ontario case of R. v. Picard shows how a stay for delay can be reversed on appeal. In R. v. Picard, 2016 ONSC 7061, the trial judge found that the accused’s right to be tried within a reasonable time had been breached and entered a stay of proceedings on murder charges (para. 1). The trial was scheduled to end 48 months after the charge; after deducting 8 months, the judge found 40 months of delay. She found that the case was not particularly complex and that the Crown had not shown reasonable reliance on the previous law (paras. 48 to 50 and 72).

The Crown appealed. In R. v. Picard, 2017 ONCA 692, the Court of Appeal for Ontario found that the trial judge had significantly overstated the institutional delay under the former framework (para. 74) and had not properly considered the case’s moderate complexity in the transitional assessment. It also noted that the parties had no meaningful opportunity to change course after Jordan was released (paras. 138 and 140). The Court allowed the appeal, dismissed the section 11(b) application, lifted the stay and sent the case back to the Superior Court for trial (para. 142).

A stay is not the same as an acquittal

A stay of proceedings for unreasonable delay ends the prosecution, but it is not a finding that the person is not guilty. The Supreme Court explained in R. v. Jewitt, [1985] 2 S.C.R. 128, that such a stay has the same practical result as an acquittal and is treated like one for the purpose of allowing a Crown appeal; otherwise, the two concepts are not the same.

Under section 676(1)(c) of the Criminal Code, the Attorney General may appeal to the court of appeal against an order of a trial court that stays proceedings on an indictment. That is what happened in Picard. So a person whose charges are stayed for delay should understand that the Crown may appeal, and that the stay can be lifted.

When does the clock stop?

In R. v. K.G.K., 2020 SCC 7, the Supreme Court clarified that the Jordan ceilings apply from the charge to the end of the evidence and argument, and no further (para. 33). Time the judge takes to deliberate and deliver a verdict is not counted toward the ceiling, but a long deliberation can still raise a section 11(b) issue that is assessed separately (para. 50).

Steps to take if your case is delayed

  1. Track the dates. Keep a record of the charge date, every court appearance, every adjournment and who asked for it.
  2. Be careful with waivers. Agreeing to an adjournment or a later date can count against you. Ask your lawyer what any request means for section 11(b) before you agree.
  3. Raise delay early. Put concerns about delay on the record and ask for the earliest available dates. Under Cody, timeliness matters.
  4. Bring a section 11(b) application in time. Courts have rules about notice and filing for Charter applications; your lawyer can prepare the application with the transcripts and the timeline.
  5. Plan for an appeal. If a stay is granted, the Crown may appeal. If an application is dismissed, there may be grounds to raise it on appeal after trial.

Common problems

  • Assuming that crossing 18 or 30 months automatically ends the case. The Crown can still prove exceptional circumstances.
  • Losing time through defence requests or waivers that are later deducted.
  • Raising delay for the first time at the last minute, which can weaken the application.
  • Treating a stay as an acquittal. The Crown can appeal, as Picard shows.
  • Forgetting the immigration side. For permanent residents and foreign nationals, any criminal outcome should also be reviewed for its effect on status.

When to get legal advice

Get legal advice as soon as you are charged, and again whenever an adjournment, a new trial date or a waiver is being discussed. A criminal lawyer can calculate the delay, identify what may be deducted, and decide whether and when to bring a section 11(b) application. If you are not a Canadian citizen, ask for advice on the immigration consequences as well. You can learn more about our criminal law services and our criminal defence services in Toronto.

Related reading: how to remove a criminal record in Canada and DUI and immigration status in Canada.

Key takeaways

  • Section 11(b) of the Charter gives a person charged with an offence the right to be tried within a reasonable time.
  • R. v. Jordan, 2016 SCC 27 set presumptive ceilings of 18 months (provincial court) and 30 months (superior court, or provincial court after a preliminary inquiry).
  • Defence-waived and defence-caused delay is subtracted; legitimate defence steps are not.
  • The Crown can justify delay above the ceiling with discrete events or a particularly complex case.
  • Below the ceiling, the defence must show sustained efforts to expedite and that the case took markedly longer than it should have.
  • A stay is not an acquittal; the Crown may appeal under section 676(1)(c) of the Criminal Code, and in Picard the stay was lifted.

Official sources

Frequently asked questions

What is the Jordan decision?

R. v. Jordan, 2016 SCC 27 is the Supreme Court of Canada decision that set presumptive time limits for criminal trials under section 11(b) of the Charter: 18 months in provincial court and 30 months in superior court, or in provincial court after a preliminary inquiry.

When does the Jordan clock start?

Delay is measured from the date the person is charged to the actual or anticipated end of the trial. Under R. v. K.G.K., 2020 SCC 7, the ceiling ends at the end of the evidence and argument, not when the verdict is delivered.

Does crossing the 18 or 30 month ceiling mean my case is automatically stayed?

No. Delay above the ceiling is presumed unreasonable, but the Crown can try to justify it with exceptional circumstances, such as a discrete event or a particularly complex case. Defence delay is also subtracted first.

What counts as defence delay?

Delay the defence clearly waived, and delay caused solely or directly by the defence, such as when the court and the Crown are ready but the defence is not. Legitimate steps taken to respond to the charges are not deducted (R. v. Cody, 2017 SCC 31, para. 30).

Can my case be stayed if the delay is below the ceiling?

Yes, but it is harder. The defence must show that it took meaningful, sustained steps to expedite the case and that the case took markedly longer than it reasonably should have (Jordan, para. 82).

Is a stay of proceedings the same as being found not guilty?

No. A stay ends the prosecution, but it is not a finding of innocence. It is treated like an acquittal only to allow the Crown to appeal (R. v. Jewitt, [1985] 2 S.C.R. 128).

Can the Crown appeal a stay for delay?

Yes. Section 676(1)(c) of the Criminal Code allows the Attorney General to appeal an order of a trial court that stays proceedings on an indictment. In R. v. Picard, 2017 ONCA 692, the Court of Appeal for Ontario lifted a stay of murder charges and sent the case back for trial.

What happened in R. v. Picard?

The trial judge stayed murder charges for delay in 2016 ONSC 7061. The Court of Appeal found that the judge had overstated the institutional delay and had not properly considered the case’s moderate complexity in the transitional assessment, so it lifted the stay and sent the case back for trial.

What was the delay in the Jordan case itself?

The total delay was 49.5 months. After subtracting 5.5 months of defence delay, the net delay was 44 months. The Supreme Court set aside the convictions and entered a stay of proceedings.

Should I agree to an adjournment?

Speak with your lawyer first. Agreeing to an adjournment or a later date may be treated as a waiver or as defence delay, which can be subtracted from the total.

Does a criminal charge affect my immigration status?

It can. Permanent residents and foreign nationals should get advice on the immigration consequences of any criminal outcome, including convictions, as well as on the criminal case itself.

Does the Jordan framework apply in British Columbia and Ontario?

Yes. Section 11(b) is a Charter right, and Jordan applies to criminal cases across Canada, including the courts of British Columbia and Ontario.

Book a consultation

If your criminal case is taking a long time, a lawyer at Pax Law Corporation can review the timeline with you.

Follow Pax Law Corporation

For more on Canadian law: subscribe on YouTube · Instagram @paxlawcorp · TikTok @paxlaw

Disclaimer: This article is general legal information only, not legal advice. It reflects the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Criminal Code and the court decisions cited as of the date of publication. Laws change and every case is different, so speak with a lawyer about your own circumstances. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Table of Contents

Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529