Employment Law
Constructive Dismissal in BC and Ontario: When a Job Change Counts as Being Fired
Reading Time
7 MINUTE READ
Constructive Dismissal in BC and Ontario: When a Job Change Counts as Being Fired
Constructive dismissal happens when an employer makes a substantial, unilateral change to an essential term of your job, such as your pay, duties or workplace, or treats you in a way that shows it no longer intends to be bound by the employment contract. The Supreme Court of Canada set out this two-branch test in Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10. If it applies, the law may treat you as dismissed, even though you were never told you were fired.
This article explains how constructive dismissal works in British Columbia and Ontario in plain language. It is general legal information, not legal advice. For help with your situation, see our employment law services, our wrongful dismissal page and our guide to severance pay in BC.
In this article
- What is constructive dismissal?
- The legal test from the Supreme Court of Canada
- Common examples
- Temporary layoffs
- What the employment standards statutes say
- Acting in time: acceptance and condonation
- Mitigation: do you have to accept another role?
- Do the COVID-era layoff rules still matter?
- Practical first steps
- When to get legal advice
- Key takeaways
- Frequently asked questions
Watch the video above, and subscribe to the Pax Law Corporation YouTube channel for more videos on Canadian law.
What is constructive dismissal?
Most people think of dismissal as being told, “You are fired.” Constructive dismissal is different. The employer does not say the job is over, but it changes the deal so much, or behaves so badly, that the law may treat the employment as ended by the employer.
If you were constructively dismissed, you may be entitled to the same remedies as an employee who was dismissed without cause, such as reasonable notice or pay in place of notice, subject to your contract and the employment standards legislation that applies to you.
The legal test from the Supreme Court of Canada
In Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10, at paragraphs 32 and 33, the Supreme Court described two branches:
- A breach of an essential term. The court identifies an express or implied term that was breached, then asks whether the breach was serious enough. Typically this involves changes to compensation, work assignments or place of work that are both unilateral and substantial.
- A course of conduct. Even without a specific broken term, the employer’s treatment of the employee can show that it no longer intends to be bound by the contract, for example where continued employment has become intolerable.
The test is objective. Following Farber v. Royal Trust Co., [1997] 1 S.C.R. 846, at paragraph 26, the question is whether a reasonable person in the employee’s situation would have felt that the essential terms of the contract were being substantially changed.
Common examples
Whether a change is serious enough always depends on the facts. Situations that often raise the question include:
- a significant cut to salary, commission or benefits;
- a demotion or a major change in duties, title or reporting lines;
- a forced move to a distant work location;
- a large cut to guaranteed hours;
- a layoff that the contract does not allow;
- harassment or humiliating treatment that the employer allows to continue.
Small or reasonable adjustments that the contract allows are usually not constructive dismissal.
Temporary layoffs
Many employees assume an employer can always lay them off “temporarily.” Under the common law, that is not the general rule. In Pham v. Qualified Metal Fabricators Ltd., 2023 ONCA 255, at paragraph 29, the Ontario Court of Appeal confirmed that, absent an express or implied term allowing it, a unilateral layoff is a substantial change that constitutes constructive dismissal, even if the layoff is temporary.
In British Columbia, Supreme Court decisions have reached similar results where there was no contractual authority for the layoff, including Davies v. Fraser Collection Services Limited, 2008 BCSC 942, at paragraph 32, and Hogan v. 1187938 B.C. Ltd., 2021 BCSC 1021, at paragraph 37. The BC Court of Appeal has not issued a majority ruling squarely deciding this common-law question.
The employment standards statutes also define “temporary layoff.” Under the BC Employment Standards Act, for an employee without a right of recall, a temporary layoff is generally a layoff of up to 13 weeks in any period of 20 consecutive weeks, and “termination of employment” includes a layoff other than a temporary layoff (section 1). Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 has its own definition in section 56(2).
What the employment standards statutes say
British Columbia. Section 66 of the Employment Standards Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 113, says: “If a condition of employment is substantially altered, the director may determine that the employment of an employee has been terminated.” This is a discretionary power of the Director of Employment Standards. If employment is found to have been terminated, section 63 sets minimum compensation for length of service: 1 week’s wages after 3 consecutive months, 2 weeks’ wages after 12 consecutive months, and 3 weeks’ wages after 3 consecutive years plus 1 week for each additional year, to a maximum of 8 weeks.
Ontario. Under section 56(1)(b) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41, an employer terminates employment if it constructively dismisses the employee and the employee resigns in response “within a reasonable period.” Section 8(1) preserves civil remedies, subject to section 97, which deals with choosing between an employment standards complaint and a lawsuit for the same matter.
The statutes set minimums. A court claim at common law may lead to a longer notice period, depending on the contract and the circumstances.
Acting in time: acceptance and condonation
Timing matters. An employee who keeps working under the new terms for a long time without objecting may be found to have accepted the change, which is called condonation. In McGuinty v. 1845035 Ontario Inc. (McGuinty Funeral Home), 2020 ONCA 816, at paragraphs 24 and 26, the Ontario Court of Appeal explained that condonation is a defence the employer must prove, that continuing to work is not automatically acceptance, and that employees must have a reasonable period of time to try to resolve workplace problems.
In Wronko v. Western Inventory Service Ltd., 2008 ONCA 327, at paragraph 36, the Court of Appeal held that where an employee clearly rejects a new term and the employer lets the employee keep working, the employee may insist on the original contract unless the employer gives proper notice of the change. Putting your objection in writing early helps show you did not agree.
Mitigation: do you have to accept another role?
A dismissed employee generally has a duty to take reasonable steps to reduce their losses, which is called mitigation. That does not mean you must accept every offer. In Brake v. PJ-M2R Restaurant Inc., 2017 ONCA 402, at paragraph 74, the Ontario Court of Appeal held that the question is whether a reasonable person in the employee’s position would have accepted the employer’s offer of a different position, that the employer bears the burden of proof, and that an employee is not obliged to work in an atmosphere of hostility, embarrassment or humiliation.
Keep a record of your job search, applications and interviews after you leave. Courts look at what you actually did to find new work.
Do the COVID-era layoff rules still matter?
During the pandemic, both provinces changed their layoff rules for a time. In British Columbia, section 45.01 of the Employment Standards Regulation extended the definition of temporary layoff for COVID-related layoffs, but only for periods ending on or before August 30, 2020. In Ontario, Ontario Regulation 228/20 applied during a “COVID-19 period” that ended on July 30, 2022.
These special rules do not apply to new layoffs or changes today. They can still matter for older claims about events inside those periods, and Ontario trial-level courts have disagreed about their effect on common-law claims.
Practical first steps
- Write it down: note what changed, when and who told you, and keep the letter, email or new schedule.
- Keep your records: your employment contract, offer letter, policies, pay stubs and performance reviews.
- Object in writing: if you do not agree to the change, say so clearly and politely, and keep a copy.
- Do not resign in a rush: quitting too early, or staying too long without objecting, can both affect your claim.
- Check deadlines: employment standards complaints and court claims have time limits.
- Get advice: a lawyer can assess whether the change is serious enough and what your options are.
When to get legal advice
Speak with a lawyer before you resign, accept a new role, or sign anything, including a release. Constructive dismissal claims depend on the exact wording of your contract, the size and nature of the change, how you responded and when. Early advice can help you avoid steps that weaken your position, such as quietly continuing under new terms for months.
Key takeaways
- Constructive dismissal can occur without the word “fired” ever being used.
- The test comes from Potter, 2015 SCC 10, and Farber, [1997] 1 S.C.R. 846: a substantial unilateral change to an essential term, or conduct showing the employer no longer intends to be bound.
- In BC, section 66 of the Employment Standards Act lets the Director find that employment was terminated; in Ontario, section 56(1)(b) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 requires resignation within a reasonable period.
- A layoff without a contractual right can be constructive dismissal.
- Object in writing, keep records, and get advice before you quit.
Frequently asked questions
What is constructive dismissal?
It is when an employer makes a substantial unilateral change to an essential term of the job, or behaves in a way that shows it no longer intends to be bound by the contract, so the law treats the employee as dismissed (Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10, paras 32-33).
Is a pay cut constructive dismissal?
It can be. A significant, unilateral cut to pay is a common example, but whether it is serious enough depends on the size of the cut, the contract and the circumstances.
Is a temporary layoff constructive dismissal?
Without an express or implied contractual right to lay off, a unilateral layoff can be constructive dismissal even if it is temporary (Pham v. Qualified Metal Fabricators Ltd., 2023 ONCA 255, para 29; Hogan v. 1187938 B.C. Ltd., 2021 BCSC 1021).
What does section 66 of the BC Employment Standards Act say?
If a condition of employment is substantially altered, the Director of Employment Standards may determine that the employee’s employment has been terminated.
What does Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 say?
Under section 56(1)(b), an employer terminates employment if it constructively dismisses the employee and the employee resigns in response within a reasonable period.
How much compensation does the BC Employment Standards Act require?
Section 63 sets minimums: 1 week’s wages after 3 consecutive months, 2 weeks after 12 consecutive months, and 3 weeks after 3 consecutive years plus 1 week per additional year, to a maximum of 8 weeks. A common-law claim may lead to more.
If I keep working, have I accepted the change?
Not automatically. Condonation is a defence the employer must prove, and employees get a reasonable time to try to resolve the problem (McGuinty v. 1845035 Ontario Inc., 2020 ONCA 816, paras 24 and 26). Objecting in writing helps.
Should I quit right away?
Not without advice. Resigning too early, or staying too long without objecting, can both affect a claim. A lawyer can help you decide when and how to respond.
Do I have to accept a different job offered by my employer?
Not always. The question is whether a reasonable person in your position would accept it, and you are not obliged to work in an atmosphere of hostility, embarrassment or humiliation (Brake v. PJ-M2R Restaurant Inc., 2017 ONCA 402, para 74).
Can a toxic workplace be constructive dismissal?
Yes, under the second branch of the test, where the employer’s treatment of the employee shows it no longer intends to be bound by the contract, for example by making continued employment intolerable (Potter, para 33).
Do the COVID-era layoff rules still apply?
No, not to new events. BC’s extended temporary layoff rule ended in 2020 and Ontario Regulation 228/20 applied to a COVID-19 period that ended on July 30, 2022. They can still matter for older claims.
Book a consultation
If your employer has changed your job or laid you off, a lawyer at Pax Law Corporation can review your situation and explain your options.
- Vancouver: Book a consultation — 215-1433 Lonsdale Avenue, North Vancouver, BC V7M 2H9 — +1-604-767-9529
- Toronto: Book a consultation — 10th Floor, 4711 Yonge Street, Toronto, ON M2N 6K8
Follow Pax Law Corporation
For more on Canadian law: subscribe on YouTube · Instagram @paxlawcorp · TikTok @paxlaw
Disclaimer: This article is general legal information only, not legal advice. It reflects the law of British Columbia and Ontario as of the date of publication. Laws change and every case is different, so speak with a lawyer about your own circumstances.
Table of Contents
- You might be interested in...

Statutory Declarations in Canada: What They Are and How to Make One
Statutory declarations in Canada explained: Canada Evidence Act s. 41, BC Evidence Act s. 69, Ontario rules, affidavits, IMM 5409 and how to prepare.

Absolute vs Conditional Discharge in Canada: Is It a Criminal Record?
Conditional discharge vs absolute discharge in Canada: when a judge can grant one (Criminal Code s. 730), the 1-year and 3-year record rules, and breach risks.

Small Claims Court in BC: Limits, Deadlines and Replies
Small claims court in BC explained: the $35,000 limit, when claims of $5,000 or less go to the CRT, the 2-year limitation period and the 14-day reply deadline.


0 Comments