Criminal Law
Absolute vs Conditional Discharge in Canada: Is It a Criminal Record?
Reading Time
7 MINUTE READ
Absolute vs Conditional Discharge in Canada: Is It a Criminal Record?
A conditional discharge or an absolute discharge is a sentence under section 730 of the Criminal Code where the judge finds you guilty but does not convict you. An absolute discharge has no conditions; a conditional discharge comes with a probation order. Either way, section 730(3) deems you not to have been convicted, and under section 6.1 of the Criminal Records Act federal records of the discharge must not be disclosed without the Minister’s approval once 1 year (absolute) or 3 years (conditional) have passed.
This article explains how discharges work in BC and Ontario in plain language. It is general legal information, not legal advice. For help with a criminal charge, see our criminal law services and our guide on what to do if you are arrested.
In this article
- What is a discharge?
- When can a judge grant a discharge?
- How judges apply the test
- Absolute discharge vs conditional discharge
- Are you convicted after a discharge?
- What happens to your record
- Breaching a conditional discharge
- Discharges and immigration
- Practical first steps
- When to get legal advice
- Key takeaways
- Frequently asked questions
Watch the video above, and subscribe to the Pax Law Corporation YouTube channel for more videos on Canadian law.
What is a discharge?
A discharge is one of the sentencing options in Canadian criminal law. It is only possible after you plead guilty or are found guilty. Instead of entering a conviction, the judge orders that you be discharged, either absolutely or on conditions. The rule is in section 730 of the Criminal Code, RSC 1985, c. C-46, which applies across Canada, including British Columbia and Ontario.
A discharge is different from an acquittal (a finding of not guilty) and from a stay or withdrawal of charges. With a discharge, there is still a finding of guilt, but no conviction is recorded.
When can a judge grant a discharge?
Under section 730(1), a discharge is available only if three conditions are met:
- the accused is a person, not an organization;
- the offence does not carry a minimum punishment prescribed by law, and is not punishable by imprisonment for 14 years or for life; and
- the judge considers a discharge to be in the best interests of the accused and not contrary to the public interest.
If the offence falls outside these limits, a discharge is not possible, whatever the circumstances.
How judges apply the test
In R. v. Fallofield (1973), 13 C.C.C. (2d) 450 (B.C.C.A.), the Court of Appeal for British Columbia explained that the judge first asks whether a discharge is in the accused’s best interests, and then whether it is not contrary to the public interest. The Court said that, generally, the first condition presupposes a person of good character, without a previous conviction, for whom a conviction is not needed for deterrence or rehabilitation and may have significant adverse repercussions. It also warned that discharges should not be applied routinely to any particular offence.
In R. v. Sanchez-Pino, [1973] 2 O.R. 314 (C.A.), the Court of Appeal for Ontario said the judge must consider all the circumstances of the accused and of the offence. More recently, in R. v. Mills, 2022 ONCA 404, at para. 12, the Court of Appeal for Ontario held that adding a requirement of “exceptionality” on top of the statutory test distorted the analysis.
Absolute discharge vs conditional discharge
An absolute discharge takes effect right away and has no conditions. A conditional discharge comes with the conditions of a probation order made under section 731(2) of the Criminal Code, such as keeping the peace, reporting to a probation officer, or staying away from certain people or places. The conditions last for the period set in the probation order.
Are you convicted after a discharge?
No. Section 730(3) says that when a court discharges an offender, the offender “shall be deemed not to have been convicted of the offence”. There are limited exceptions: you may still appeal the finding of guilt as if it were a conviction, the Crown may appeal the decision not to convict, and you may rely on the discharge if you are charged again for the same offence.
What happens to your record
Under section 6.1(1) of the Criminal Records Act, RSC 1985, c. C-47, a record of a discharge held by the RCMP Commissioner or any federal department or agency must not be disclosed to anyone without the prior approval of the Minister once:
- 1 year has passed since an absolute discharge; or
- 3 years have passed since the day a conditional discharge was ordered.
Section 6.1(2) requires the Commissioner to remove all references to the discharge from the RCMP’s automated criminal conviction records system at the end of that period. The Act does not say every record everywhere is erased, and section 6.2 allows limited disclosure in specific situations, such as fingerprint identification. A record suspension is not needed for a discharge.
Breaching a conditional discharge
A breach does not automatically cancel a conditional discharge. Under section 730(4), if you are bound by the probation order and are convicted of an offence, including failing to comply with the probation order under section 733.1, the court that made the order may revoke the discharge, convict you of the original offence, and impose any sentence that could have been imposed at the time of the discharge. Section 733.1 applies to a failure or refusal to comply “without reasonable excuse”.
Discharges and immigration
The conviction-based grounds of inadmissibility in sections 36(1)(a) and 36(2)(a) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act require that a person have been “convicted in Canada”. Because section 730(3) deems a discharged offender not convicted, a Canadian discharge is generally not a conviction for those provisions. In Idelfonso v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 392, at para. 27, the Federal Court said that, unlike an unresolved charge, a completed conditional discharge could not give rise to potential grounds of inadmissibility.
This is not a blanket exemption. Other parts of section 36 deal with acts committed outside Canada, and immigration forms often ask about charges and arrests, not only convictions. Answer every form accurately; a wrong answer can raise misrepresentation concerns. Other countries apply their own laws, so get advice before you travel or apply for a visa. See our article on criminal inadmissibility under IRPA section 36.
Practical first steps
- Keep your paperwork: the court order, the probation order and your court file number.
- Follow every condition: report as required, keep the peace, and keep proof of completed programs or community work.
- Note the key dates: the date of the discharge order and the date your probation ends.
- Answer forms accurately: read immigration, travel and employment forms carefully; some ask about charges or findings of guilt, not only convictions.
- Get advice before you plead: whether a discharge is realistic depends on the offence and your circumstances.
When to get legal advice
Speak with a lawyer as soon as you are charged, before you decide how to plead. A lawyer can tell you whether the offence makes a discharge possible, what evidence can support a request for one, and how a sentence may affect your immigration status, job or travel. Get advice right away if you are accused of breaching a probation order.
Key takeaways
- A discharge under section 730 of the Criminal Code follows a finding of guilt, but no conviction is entered.
- It is not available for offences with a minimum punishment or a maximum of 14 years or life.
- An absolute discharge has no conditions; a conditional discharge comes with probation.
- Federal records of a discharge are not to be disclosed after 1 year (absolute) or 3 years (conditional) without the Minister’s approval.
- A new conviction while on probation can lead the court to revoke the discharge and convict you.
- A Canadian discharge is generally not a conviction under IRPA sections 36(1)(a) and 36(2)(a), but forms must still be answered accurately.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an absolute and a conditional discharge?
An absolute discharge has no conditions. A conditional discharge comes with the conditions of a probation order (Criminal Code s. 730(1)).
Do I have a criminal conviction after a discharge?
No. Section 730(3) of the Criminal Code deems a discharged offender not to have been convicted of the offence.
Which offences are not eligible for a discharge?
Offences with a minimum punishment prescribed by law, and offences punishable by imprisonment for 14 years or for life (s. 730(1)).
What does the judge consider?
Whether a discharge is in the best interests of the accused and not contrary to the public interest (s. 730(1); R. v. Fallofield; R. v. Sanchez-Pino).
When will an absolute discharge stop being disclosed?
Federal records of an absolute discharge are not to be disclosed without the Minister’s approval once more than 1 year has passed (Criminal Records Act s. 6.1(1)(a)).
When will a conditional discharge stop being disclosed?
Once more than 3 years have passed since the day the conditional discharge was ordered (Criminal Records Act s. 6.1(1)(b)).
Is the discharge removed from the RCMP database?
Yes. Section 6.1(2) of the Criminal Records Act requires the RCMP Commissioner to remove references to the discharge from its automated criminal conviction records system at the end of the relevant period.
Do I need a record suspension for a discharge?
No. The Criminal Records Act deals with discharges separately in section 6.1, so no record suspension application is needed for a discharge.
What happens if I breach my probation conditions?
If you are convicted of an offence while bound by the probation order, including breach under s. 733.1, the court may revoke the discharge, convict you and impose a new sentence (s. 730(4)).
Can a discharge affect immigration?
A Canadian discharge is generally not a conviction under IRPA ss. 36(1)(a) and 36(2)(a), but other grounds exist and forms must be answered accurately. Get advice for your situation.
Can I appeal a discharge?
Yes. Section 730(3)(a) lets the offender appeal the finding of guilt as if it were a conviction, and the Crown may appeal the decision not to convict.
Book a consultation
If you are facing a criminal charge or have questions about a discharge, a lawyer at Pax Law Corporation can review your situation and explain your options.
- Vancouver: Book a consultation — 215-1433 Lonsdale Avenue, North Vancouver, BC V7M 2H9 — +1-604-767-9529
- Toronto: Book a consultation — 10th Floor, 4711 Yonge Street, Toronto, ON M2N 6K8
Follow Pax Law Corporation
For more on Canadian law: subscribe on YouTube · Instagram @paxlawcorp · TikTok @paxlaw
Disclaimer: This article is general legal information only, not legal advice. It reflects federal law as it applies in British Columbia and Ontario as of the date of publication. Laws change and every case is different, so speak with a lawyer about your own circumstances.
Table of Contents
- You might be interested in...

Small Claims Court in BC: Limits, Deadlines and Replies
Small claims court in BC explained: the $35,000 limit, when claims of $5,000 or less go to the CRT, the 2-year limitation period and the 14-day reply deadline.

BC Company Annual Report: What Happens If You Miss It
BC annual report filing explained: the 2-month deadline under s. 51, how missed reports lead to dissolution under s. 422, and how to restore a company.

Probate in BC: How the Process Works, Step by Step
How probate works in BC: probate vs administration, the 21-day notice under Rule 25-2, the forms, probate fees, the executor’s duties and the 210-day rule.


0 Comments