Immigration and Refugee Law

Security Inadmissibility to Canada: IRPA s. 34 Grounds, Membership, Hearings and Ministerial Relief

Reading Time

10 MINUTE READ

Security Inadmissibility to Canada: IRPA s. 34 Grounds, Membership, Hearings and Ministerial Relief

Section 34 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) makes a permanent resident or a foreign national inadmissible to Canada on “security grounds”. These grounds cover espionage, subversion, terrorism, being a danger to the security of Canada, certain acts of violence and membership in certain organizations. A security finding can lead to a refused application, the loss of permanent resident status or a removal order.

This article explains in plain English what security inadmissibility is, the legal test that applies, how each ground has been interpreted by the courts, how the process works from a procedural fairness letter to a hearing, and what options may be available, including ministerial relief and judicial review in the Federal Court.

In this article

  1. What is security inadmissibility?
  2. Who it affects
  3. The legal standard: reasonable grounds to believe
  4. Espionage and subversion: s. 34(1)(a), (b) and (b.1)
  5. Terrorism: s. 34(1)(c)
  6. Danger to security and acts of violence: s. 34(1)(d) and (e)
  7. Membership in an organization: s. 34(1)(f)
  8. How the process works
  9. Ministerial relief under s. 42.1
  10. Steps to take and common problems
  11. Judicial review in the Federal Court
  12. When to get legal advice
  13. Key takeaways
  14. Official sources
  15. Frequently asked questions

Watch: Security Inadmissibility to Canada Explained

For more videos on Canadian law, subscribe to the Pax Law Corporation YouTube channel.

What is security inadmissibility?

“Inadmissible” means a person is not allowed to enter or remain in Canada. Section 34(1) of IRPA lists six security grounds. A permanent resident or a foreign national is inadmissible on security grounds for:

  • (a) engaging in an act of espionage that is against Canada or that is contrary to Canada’s interests;
  • (b) engaging in or instigating the subversion by force of any government;
  • (b.1) engaging in an act of subversion against a democratic government, institution or process as they are understood in Canada;
  • (c) engaging in terrorism;
  • (d) being a danger to the security of Canada;
  • (e) engaging in acts of violence that would or might endanger the lives or safety of persons in Canada; or
  • (f) being a member of an organization that there are reasonable grounds to believe engages, has engaged or will engage in acts referred to in paragraph (a), (b), (b.1) or (c).

A security finding does not require a criminal conviction. It is an immigration decision, made on an immigration standard of proof.

Who it affects

Section 34 applies to both permanent residents and foreign nationals (visitors, students, workers, refugee claimants and applicants for permanent residence). It most often arises when:

  • an applicant for a visa, permit or permanent residence goes through security screening;
  • an officer has information about a person’s past work, military service, political activity or associations;
  • a permanent resident in Canada becomes the subject of a report under s. 44 of IRPA.

Membership questions are explained in more detail in our article on membership and procedural fairness letters under s. 34(1)(f). Former senior officials of designated regimes face a separate ground under s. 35(1)(b), explained in our article on senior official inadmissibility.

The legal standard: reasonable grounds to believe

Section 33 of IRPA says that the facts that make a person inadmissible under sections 34 to 37 include facts arising from omissions and, unless otherwise provided, facts for which there are “reasonable grounds to believe that they have occurred, are occurring or may occur”.

In Mugesera v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2005 SCC 40, the Supreme Court of Canada explained that this standard requires more than mere suspicion but less than proof on a balance of probabilities. Reasonable grounds exist where there is an objective basis for the belief, based on compelling and credible information (para. 114).

In practice, this means the government does not have to prove its case “more likely than not”. It does mean that the evidence must be credible and specific, and that a decision-maker must explain how the evidence supports each part of the ground relied on.

Espionage and subversion: s. 34(1)(a), (b) and (b.1)

Espionage. The Federal Court has described espionage as surreptitious or covert information gathering. In Peer v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2010 FC 752, the Court treated secret information-gathering on behalf of an intelligence service as espionage. In Sumaida v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2018 FC 256, the Court said the 2013 change in the wording of s. 34(1)(a) did not suggest a departure from the earlier case law.

The Federal Court of Appeal has also set an important limit. In Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness) v. Weldemariam, 2024 FCA 69, it held that a person can only be found inadmissible under s. 34(1)(a), or under s. 34(1)(f) based on espionage, where the espionage is directed against Canada or has a nexus to Canada’s national security or security interests (para. 118).

Subversion by force. In Najafi v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2014 FCA 262, the Federal Court of Appeal held that the words “subversion by force of any government” in s. 34(1)(b) are clear and do not imply any qualification about the legitimacy of the government in question. The ground still requires subversion “by force”. Paragraph (b.1) is a separate ground with different wording, which deals with subversion against a democratic government, institution or process as understood in Canada.

Terrorism: s. 34(1)(c)

IRPA does not define “terrorism”. In Suresh v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2002 SCC 1, the Supreme Court of Canada said terrorism includes any act intended to cause death or serious bodily injury to a civilian, or to any other person not taking an active part in hostilities in a situation of armed conflict, when the purpose of the act is to intimidate a population or to compel a government or an international organization to do or abstain from doing any act (para. 98). The Court noted that it was not giving an exhaustive definition.

Section 83.01 of the Criminal Code separately defines “terrorist activity” for criminal law purposes. That definition includes a political, religious or ideological purpose element and an intimidation or compulsion element, and it excludes advocacy, protest, dissent or stoppage of work that is not intended to cause the listed serious harms. Section 34(1)(c) of IRPA does not expressly refer to the Criminal Code, but decision-makers and courts sometimes look to it for guidance.

Danger to security and acts of violence: s. 34(1)(d) and (e)

Danger to the security of Canada. In Suresh, the Supreme Court held that a person is a danger to the security of Canada if they pose a serious threat to Canada’s security, direct or indirect. The threat must be grounded on an objectively reasonable suspicion based on evidence, and the threatened harm must be substantial rather than negligible (para. 90). In S. R. v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2019 FC 1118, the Federal Court stressed that the decision-maker must explain how the facts amount to a threat to the security of Canada, not just a threat to individuals.

Acts of violence. In Mason v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2023 SCC 21, the Supreme Court of Canada held that s. 34(1)(e) can be used only when the acts of violence that would or might endanger the lives or safety of persons in Canada have a nexus with national security or the security of Canada (paras. 121 to 123). Ordinary criminal violence without that security connection is dealt with under the criminality rules, not under s. 34(1)(e).

Membership in an organization: s. 34(1)(f)

Membership is the ground most often used. The officer must have reasonable grounds to believe both that the person is or was a member, and that the organization engages, has engaged or will engage in espionage, subversion or terrorism under paragraph (a), (b), (b.1) or (c). Paragraph (f) does not refer to paragraphs (d) or (e).

  • “Member” is read broadly. In Poshteh v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2005 FCA 85, the Federal Court of Appeal rejected a “significant integration” test (paras. 29 and 31).
  • Minors. Poshteh also held there is no blanket exemption for minors, but the decision-maker must consider whether the minor had the knowledge or mental capacity to understand the nature and effect of their actions, on a continuum based on age (paras. 40, 47 and 51).
  • No complicity analysis. In Kanagendren v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FCA 86, the Federal Court of Appeal held that s. 34(1)(f) does not require a complicity analysis or proof that the person contributed significantly to the group’s wrongful acts (para. 22). Membership itself must still be established.
  • Timing. In Anteneh v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2023 FC 513, the Federal Court explained that membership is without temporal constraints, so the person’s membership does not have to coincide with the organization’s acts (para. 28). In Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness) v. Ubah, 2025 FC 1241, the Court explained that where the organization’s acts came later, the question is whether, at the time of the person’s membership, there were reasonable grounds to believe the organization would engage in such acts (para. 41).

How the process works

Procedural fairness letter. When an officer has concerns about an applicant, the officer usually sends a procedural fairness letter setting out the concerns and giving the person a chance to respond in writing by a deadline. The response is often the most important opportunity to correct the record.

Report and referral. For a person in Canada, an officer who believes the person is inadmissible may prepare a report under s. 44(1) of IRPA. If the Minister’s delegate considers the report well-founded, it may be referred to the Immigration Division of the Immigration and Refugee Board for an admissibility hearing (s. 44(2)).

Admissibility hearing. At the end of the hearing, the Immigration Division makes one of the decisions listed in s. 45, which can include a removal order against a permanent resident or a foreign national found inadmissible.

Non-disclosure of evidence. Under s. 86, the Minister may apply during an admissibility hearing, a detention review or an Immigration Appeal Division appeal for the non-disclosure of information. In that process, the special advocate provisions apply with any necessary modifications. This is not automatic in every hearing.

Security certificates. Section 77 sets out a separate process in which two ministers sign a security certificate and refer it to the Federal Court, which decides whether the certificate is reasonable. This process is rare and is different from an ordinary admissibility hearing.

Ministerial relief under s. 42.1

Before 2013, relief from security inadmissibility was in s. 34(2). That subsection was repealed in 2013 and replaced by s. 42.1. Under s. 42.1, the Minister may, on application by a foreign national or on the Minister’s own initiative, declare that the matters in section 34, paragraph 35(1)(b) and subsection 37(1) do not constitute inadmissibility if satisfied that it is not contrary to the national interest. Under s. 42.1(3), the Minister may only take into account national security and public safety considerations, but is not limited to considering the danger the foreign national presents.

Agraira v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2013 SCC 36, interpreted the former s. 34(2), not the current s. 42.1. In Abdulimiti v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2024 FC 1960, the Federal Court explained that s. 42.1(3) does not exclude a broader range of factors from the analysis, and that ministerial relief is not a substitute for a humanitarian and compassionate review.

Steps to take and common problems

  1. Read the letter carefully. Identify which paragraph of s. 34(1) is relied on and every factual concern raised.
  2. Note the deadline. Ask for an extension in writing before the deadline if you need more time to gather documents.
  3. Gather evidence. Collect documents about your role, dates, duties and the organization, and statements from people with direct knowledge.
  4. Address each element. For membership, deal with both whether you were a member and what the organization did. For espionage and acts of violence, address the link to Canada’s security.
  5. Be accurate and consistent. Your answers should match what you said in earlier forms and interviews. Inaccurate answers can create a separate misrepresentation problem under s. 40 of IRPA.

Common problems include responding only with general denials, ignoring the organization’s history, providing documents without translations, and not explaining duties performed under compulsion or as a minor.

Judicial review in the Federal Court

A refusal or a decision based on s. 34 can usually be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review in the Federal Court under s. 72(1) of IRPA. The Court does not rehear the case; it reviews whether the decision was reasonable and procedurally fair. Strict deadlines apply.

Pax Law Corporation lawyers have Federal Court decisions published on CanLII. You can read about them on our court decisions page and learn more about immigration judicial reviews. Every case is different and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

When to get legal advice

Get legal advice as soon as you receive a procedural fairness letter, an interview request about your background, a s. 44 report or a notice of an admissibility hearing. The legal tests are technical, the deadlines are short, and what you say in your response can affect later stages, including any hearing or judicial review. A lawyer can review the evidence, identify the exact ground relied on and help you prepare a complete, accurate response. Learn more about our immigration services.

Key takeaways

  • Section 34(1) of IRPA has six security grounds: espionage, subversion, terrorism, danger to security, acts of violence and membership.
  • The standard is “reasonable grounds to believe” (s. 33; Mugesera): more than suspicion, less than a balance of probabilities.
  • Espionage and acts of violence need a link to Canada or Canada’s security (Weldemariam; Mason).
  • Membership is read broadly and does not require complicity, but minors’ knowledge and capacity must be considered (Poshteh; Kanagendren).
  • Ministerial relief under s. 42.1 and judicial review under s. 72(1) may be available.

Official sources

Frequently asked questions

What does security inadmissibility mean?

It means a permanent resident or foreign national may be refused entry or status, or lose status, on one of the security grounds in section 34(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.

What are the security grounds in section 34?

Espionage, subversion by force of any government, subversion against a democratic government, institution or process, terrorism, being a danger to the security of Canada, certain acts of violence, and membership in an organization that engages, has engaged or will engage in espionage, subversion or terrorism.

Do I need a criminal conviction to be found inadmissible on security grounds?

No. Security inadmissibility is an immigration decision. It is decided on the standard of reasonable grounds to believe, not on criminal proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

What does reasonable grounds to believe mean?

In Mugesera, 2005 SCC 40, the Supreme Court of Canada said it means more than mere suspicion but less than proof on a balance of probabilities, based on compelling and credible information.

Does espionage have to be against Canada?

Under Weldemariam, 2024 FCA 69, a finding under section 34(1)(a), or under section 34(1)(f) based on espionage, requires espionage directed against Canada or with a nexus to Canada’s national security or security interests.

Can any act of violence lead to security inadmissibility?

No. In Mason, 2023 SCC 21, the Supreme Court of Canada held that section 34(1)(e) applies only when the acts of violence have a nexus with national security or the security of Canada.

How broad is membership under section 34(1)(f)?

The Federal Court of Appeal reads member broadly and does not require significant integration (Poshteh, 2005 FCA 85) or a complicity analysis (Kanagendren, 2015 FCA 86). Membership must still be established on the evidence.

Are minors treated differently?

There is no blanket exemption for minors, but under Poshteh the decision-maker must consider whether the minor had the knowledge or mental capacity to understand the nature and effect of their actions.

What is a procedural fairness letter?

It is a letter from an officer setting out concerns about an application and giving the applicant a chance to respond in writing before a decision is made.

What is ministerial relief?

Under section 42.1 of the Act, the Minister may declare that certain matters, including those in section 34, do not constitute inadmissibility if satisfied that it is not contrary to the national interest. Only national security and public safety considerations may be taken into account.

Is there a hearing for permanent residents?

A permanent resident in Canada may be reported under section 44 and referred to the Immigration Division of the Immigration and Refugee Board for an admissibility hearing. The Division then makes a decision under section 45.

Can I challenge a security decision in court?

Many decisions can be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review in the Federal Court under section 72(1) of the Act. Strict deadlines apply, so get legal advice quickly.

Book a consultation

If you have received a procedural fairness letter or a report about security grounds, a lawyer at Pax Law Corporation can review it with you.

Follow Pax Law Corporation

For more on Canadian law: subscribe on YouTube · Instagram @paxlawcorp · TikTok @paxlaw

Disclaimer: This article is general legal information only, not legal advice. It reflects the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, the Criminal Code and the court decisions cited as of the date of publication. Laws change and every case is different, so speak with a lawyer about your own circumstances. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Table of Contents

Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529