
IRCC File Stuck in Security Screening: When Is Mandamus an Option?
A plain-language guide to IRCC security screening delays and Federal Court mandamus: the Apotex and Conille tests, recent decisions, the demand letter, risks and alternatives.
Immigration and Refugee Law
Reading Time
10 MINUTE READ
A criminal record, a charge or even an act committed outside Canada can make a person inadmissible to Canada under section 36 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA). The result can be a refused visa, work permit or permanent residence application, or, for someone already in Canada, a report and an admissibility hearing.
This article explains in plain English how criminal inadmissibility works: the difference between “serious criminality” and “criminality”, how a foreign conviction is compared to Canadian law, which records do not count, and the main ways to overcome the problem, including rehabilitation, record suspensions and temporary resident permits.
In this article
“Inadmissible” means that a person is not allowed to enter or remain in Canada. IRPA sets out several grounds of inadmissibility. Section 36 deals with crime. It has two levels: serious criminality in subsection 36(1) and criminality in subsection 36(2).
Criminal inadmissibility is not a punishment. It is an immigration consequence that flows from a conviction or, in some cases, from an act committed outside Canada. Whether it applies depends on the exact Canadian offence that matches the conduct, the maximum penalty for that offence and the sentence that was actually imposed.
Section 36 can affect:
The lower “criminality” category in subsection 36(2) applies only to foreign nationals. A permanent resident can lose status on criminal grounds only if the matter falls under serious criminality.
Under subsection 36(1), a permanent resident or foreign national is inadmissible for serious criminality for:
Paragraph (a) has two separate tests. The first looks at the maximum penalty the law allows. The second looks at the sentence the court actually imposed. Paragraphs (b) and (c) look only at the Canadian maximum penalty for the matching offence.
Under subsection 36(2), a foreign national is inadmissible for criminality for:
Former paragraph 36(2)(d) has been repealed. Under paragraph 36(3)(a), an offence that can be prosecuted either summarily or by indictment (a “hybrid” offence) is treated as indictable for these rules, even if it was actually prosecuted summarily.
For a conviction or act outside Canada, the officer or the Immigration Division must decide which Canadian offence it corresponds to. This is called equivalency. In Hill v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1987] 2 F.C. 167 (C.A.), the Federal Court of Appeal described three ways to do this:
In Brannson v. Minister of Employment and Immigration, [1981] 2 F.C. 141 (C.A.), the Court said the names and wording of the offences do not need to match, but their essential elements must correspond. In Li v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), [1997] 1 F.C. 235 (C.A.), the Court held that the comparison includes the defences particular to the offence, but it is not a retrial of the foreign case under Canadian rules of evidence.
Recent Federal Court decisions show how this works in practice. In Zeine v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2023 FC 1370, the decision was set aside because the officer did not properly analyze the essential elements and a self-defence issue. In Santiago Cruceta v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2024 FC 1194, the Immigration Division had not meaningfully addressed a defence argument. In other cases, such as Stojkova v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2025 FC 511, Hosh v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2025 FC 765 and Lottia v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2025 FC 1146, the Court upheld equivalency findings.
In 2026, the Federal Court of Appeal decided Rodriguez Anzola v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FCA 90. It held that the Immigration Division must consider the circumstances that prevented a person from raising a duress defence abroad, where that defence was otherwise legally available.
Two details often decide the outcome. First, in Tran v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2017 SCC 50, the Supreme Court of Canada held that a conditional sentence served in the community is not a “term of imprisonment” under paragraph 36(1)(a). Second, the Court held that the relevant maximum penalty is the one in force when the offence was committed, not a higher maximum introduced later.
Impaired driving is a common example. Part VIII.1 of the Criminal Code came into force on December 18, 2018. Under the current subsection 320.19(1), impaired driving prosecuted by indictment carries a maximum of 10 years, which can bring it within serious criminality. Because of Tran, the date of the offence matters.
Subsection 36(3) sets out important limits. Inadmissibility under section 36 may not be based on:
For a permanent resident, whether they committed an act outside Canada under paragraph 36(1)(c) must be decided on a balance of probabilities. Otherwise, section 33 of IRPA allows facts to be established on “reasonable grounds to believe”, a lower standard.
For convictions and acts outside Canada, paragraph 36(3)(c) allows a person to overcome inadmissibility through rehabilitation. There are two routes.
Individual rehabilitation. Under section 17 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR), a person can apply once five years have passed since the end of the sentence (for a conviction) or since the act was committed, if there has been no later conviction other than a contravention or a young offender matter. The person must satisfy the Minister that they have been rehabilitated; the passage of time alone is not enough.
Deemed rehabilitation. Under section 18 of IRPR, some people are treated as rehabilitated without applying, but only if every condition is met. For example, a person with one foreign conviction equivalent to an indictable offence with a Canadian maximum of less than 10 years may be deemed rehabilitated if at least 10 years have passed since the end of the sentence and the other conditions apply. A person with two or more foreign convictions equivalent to summary offences may qualify after five years, again only if all conditions are met. Deemed rehabilitation is not available for serious criminality.
Foreign pardons. A pardon or discharge granted abroad is not automatically recognized. In Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Saini, 2001 FCA 311, the Federal Court of Appeal required that the foreign legal system be similar to Canada’s, that the foreign law have a similar aim, content and effect, and that there be no valid reason to refuse recognition.
For convictions in Canada, rehabilitation under IRPA does not apply. Instead, a person may apply to the Parole Board of Canada for a record suspension under the Criminal Records Act. The Board has exclusive jurisdiction and absolute discretion to order or refuse one. In general, a person cannot apply until 10 years (for an offence prosecuted by indictment) or five years (for an offence punishable on summary conviction) have passed after the sentence, including probation and any fine, has been completed. A record suspension that remains in effect means the conviction cannot be used for criminal inadmissibility.
If a person is inadmissible and is not yet eligible for rehabilitation, or needs to travel urgently, subsection 24(1) of IRPA allows an officer to issue a temporary resident permit if it is justified in the circumstances. A permit is discretionary, can be cancelled at any time and does not remove the inadmissibility itself.
For people in Canada, an officer may prepare a report under subsection 44(1) of IRPA. The Minister may then refer the report to the Immigration Division for an admissibility hearing, or in some cases make a removal order directly. Before a decision, applicants often receive a procedural fairness letter asking them to respond.
An appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division may be limited. Under subsection 64(2), there is no appeal for serious criminality where the crime was punished in Canada by a term of imprisonment of at least six months, or where the matter falls under paragraph 36(1)(b) or (c). Note that this test is “at least six months”, while paragraph 36(1)(a) uses “more than six months”. Where no appeal is available, an application for leave and judicial review to the Federal Court may be an option.
Common problems include assuming a foreign offence has the same name in Canada, missing a defence that exists in Canadian law, overlooking a conditional sentence, and believing that time alone removes inadmissibility.
It is wise to speak with a lawyer if you have any criminal record, charge or police matter anywhere in the world before you apply, if you receive a procedural fairness letter, or if you are reported under section 44. The equivalency analysis is technical and the right route depends on your record and your dates. You can learn more about our immigration services and immigration judicial reviews.
Lawyers at Pax Law Corporation have Federal Court decisions published on CanLII; you can see examples on our court decisions page. Every case is different and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
It means a person may be refused entry or status, or lose status, because of a conviction or, in some cases, an act committed outside Canada. It is set out in section 36 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.
Serious criminality (s. 36(1)) involves offences with a maximum of at least 10 years, or a Canadian sentence of more than six months, and applies to permanent residents and foreign nationals. Criminality (s. 36(2)) covers other indictable or multiple offences and applies only to foreign nationals.
Only under the serious criminality rules in subsection 36(1). The lower criminality category in subsection 36(2) applies to foreign nationals.
The decision-maker identifies the Canadian offence with corresponding essential elements, including defences, using the methods described in Hill, Brannson and Li. The names of the offences do not need to match.
No. In Tran, 2017 SCC 50, the Supreme Court of Canada held that a conditional sentence is not a term of imprisonment under paragraph 36(1)(a).
The maximum penalty in force when the offence was committed, according to Tran, 2017 SCC 50.
Under the current Criminal Code subsection 320.19(1), impaired driving prosecuted by indictment carries a maximum of 10 years, which can bring it within serious criminality. The date of the offence matters.
Under IRPR section 18, some people with limited foreign records are treated as rehabilitated without applying, if every condition is met. It does not apply to serious criminality.
Under IRPR section 17, five years after the end of the sentence or after the act was committed, if there has been no later conviction other than the listed exceptions. You must satisfy the Minister that you are rehabilitated.
Yes, for Canadian convictions. A conviction covered by a record suspension that is still in effect cannot be used for criminal inadmissibility.
Not automatically. Under Saini, 2001 FCA 311, the foreign legal system and law must be similar to Canada’s and there must be no valid reason to refuse recognition.
A discretionary permit under IRPA subsection 24(1) that may allow an inadmissible person to enter or stay in Canada temporarily if justified. It does not remove the inadmissibility.
Sometimes. Subsection 64(2) bars an appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division for serious criminality in some cases. Judicial review in the Federal Court may still be possible.
If you have a criminal record or have received a procedural fairness letter about criminality, a lawyer at Pax Law Corporation can review it with you.
For more on Canadian law: subscribe on YouTube · Instagram @paxlawcorp · TikTok @paxlaw
Disclaimer: This article is general legal information only, not legal advice. It reflects the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations, the Criminal Records Act, the Criminal Code and the court decisions cited as of the date of publication. Laws change and every case is different, so speak with a lawyer about your own circumstances. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

A plain-language guide to IRCC security screening delays and Federal Court mandamus: the Apotex and Conille tests, recent decisions, the demand letter, risks and alternatives.

A plain-language guide to what happens to a bridging open work permit when the permanent residence application behind it is refused or withdrawn, including validity, cancellation, status and options.

A plain-language guide to Express Entry refusals under IRPA s. 11.2: what the law requires, how the Federal Court reviews these refusals, the 15- and 60-day deadlines, remedies and alternatives.

دفتر وکالت پکس لا
پکس لا
سلام! وقت مشاورهی خود را بهسرعت از طریق واتساپ رزرو کنید. تیم ما در اسرع وقت پاسخ خواهد داد.
Book a consultation with Pax Law Corporation and we will explain the options for your matter.
Book a consultationCall 604-767-9529This website provides general legal information only, not legal advice. Booking a consultation does not create a lawyer-client relationship until we confirm in writing. Outcomes cannot be guaranteed.
We use cookies to measure visits and improve this website. Choose whether to allow them.
0 Comments